What is Restorative Leadership?

What does it mean to lead in a world of deep uncertainty, fracture and polarization?  A restorative approach to leadership offers a simple and timely invitation: that we may use our influence to cultivate just relationships, prevent harm, and create meaningful opportunities for accountability and repair.

These turbulent times demand quick evolution in our notions and assumptions of what it means to navigate life and leadership. Visions of power, control, authority that were once taken for granted are being rightly interrogated as their costs and limitations are laid bare.  Within this era of deep and visible tension between democratic and authoritarian approaches to leadership, between ‘power-over’ and ‘power-with,’ so many of us who hunger for just relationships find ourselves searching for new models of leadership that can answer these times. The stakes in that search feel enormously high for our communities, organizations and societies.

This is not a new search, but a continued conversation with ancient origins. The last several decades alone have produced numerous luminaries whose work has stretched and informed our understanding of leadership. Margaret Wheatley’s Leadership and the New Science, which brings insights from the foundations of matter and ecosystems into organizational life; adrienne maree brown’s Emergent Strategy, which offers nourishing principles on relational, adaptive, and collaborative action for systemic transformation; the growing discipline of Inclusive Leadership, which spotlights participation, belonging, and recognition as central leadership functions; Brene Brown’s powerful work on vulnerability, courage and leadership, through books like Dare to Lead; Donna Hicks’ Leading with Dignity, which provides an insightful map for organizational leaders working intentionally to honor the dignity of others – just to name just a few! From these and so many other visionaries, a picture emerges of leadership that broadens rather than consolidates power; that leaves space for uncertainty and creativity; that folds into the center the voices of those on the margins; that recognizes our place within dynamic living systems, rather than perpetuating expired concepts of human beings as utilitarian mechanical objects.

Through our decades of practice and study, and through conversations with numerous colleagues and clients across settings, we’ve come to recognize that the principles of a restorative approach have something unique and important to offer the question of leadership. As we’ll explain, a restorative approach contributes to these evolving conversations an explicit commitment to relational and systemic accountability: commitment not only to cultivating conditions for mutual thriving, but taking responsibility for what happens when those conditions fail.

A brief translation may be necessary here. A “restorative” approach owes its terminology to the field of restorative justice, which in turn owes much of its praxis to Indigenous teachings and teachers in Canada, the United States, New Zealand and beyond. Restorative justice is, at heart, a paradigm of justice rooted in an understanding of the centrality of interconnected relationships. It’s also a term that has come to mean many things to many people – including, perhaps most commonly, as a collaborative process among people responsible for and impacted by harm, violence and injustice, toward accountability, repair and recovery. Based on that kind of procedural understanding, innovative programs and initiatives are being advanced and evaluated across the globe. But narrowing the concept to these processes alone would profoundly limit the utility of restorative justice as a genuine paradigm shift in how we understand the very concept of justice.

Justice, it turns out, is not just something that happens to (or is inflicted on) people after an occurrence of harm among individuals, groups or institutions. A restorative approach to justice is also an aspiration toward right and ‘just’ relationships in how we exist in community; what we expect of one another and of ourselves; how we honor each other’s dignity and voice; how we embrace and enfold one another into a sense of collective belonging. Restorative justice is about the way we relate and live together, both in the calm and in the storm.

There’s a genuine risk, when we talk about a “way” of relating, of getting lost in platitudes. The place where a restorative approach to justice and relationship finds meaning is through the deliberate application of principles. Put differently, a restorative approach requires us to articulate what is collectively important about the nature or quality of our daily relationships, and what we value and prioritize when these relationships break down. Drawing on our experiences and the substantial literature on restorative justice, we offer four interconnected principles that we believe can help translate a restorative paradigm into the everyday responsibilities and actions of leaders.

Dignity

All human beings have inherent worth. In honor of this fact, restorative leaders strive for empowering and inclusive processes, spaces, and cultures rather than adversarial and authoritarian ones. The voices of those affected by decisions are meaningfully included in decision-making. They strive to approach everyone in their orbit with deep respect, curiosity and positive regard. In this way, they seek to cultivate confidence within all individual constituents of a living system, about their inherent value and worth.

Belonging

Restorative leaders seek to nurture interconnection between constituent parts of the system towards an experience of wholeness. They recognize and celebrate our interconnectedness, and invite the same recognition in others.  They aspire to creating an environment that enables a sense of mutual trust, support, reciprocity and accountability. Importantly, Belonging does not equate directly with “fitting in.” While “fitting in” involves conforming to external expectations, belonging is about being accepted for oneself. In other words, true belonging can be built only when dignity is honored.

Stewardship

The principle of stewardship invites leaders to facilitate movement toward systemic evolution and change based on collective/institutional learning, resilience and adaptation. Stewardship requires communication and collaboration across the constituent parts of a system, and mechanisms for that collaboration to yield influence. It requires the pursuit of inclusion and equity in relationships, to ensure adaptation and change is informed by diverse perspectives. This principle also invites leaders to work toward strengthening the capacity and resilience of individuals and communities to adapt to change, manage conflict effectively, and prevent breakdowns in relationships.

Repair

Repair is a process of restoring or cultivating experiences of dignity, belonging and wholeness among people and groups after there have been experiences of harm, violation, crises or ruptures in relationships. Harm and injustice can take many forms, impacting individuals, relationships, communities, organizations, systems and entire societies. A restorative approach invites leaders to cultivate and normalize opportunities for repair at these multiple levels. While attending to acute and interpersonal harms, this principle also invites us to attend to harmful social/organizational conditions and structures. Restorative leaders model personal accountability, as an acceptance of responsibility coupled with actions toward making things right where possible. They also facilitate collective responsibility for addressing the causes and impacts of harm.

The invitation of restorative leadership, then, is to pay attention to the relationships and systems we are part of, recognize our influence and contribution within them, and use that influence in service of just relationship. It is a call to help shape a reality where power dynamics are acknowledged and authority is distributed; where trust and connection are prioritized; where universal human needs like dignity, belonging, genuine accountability, healing and acts of repair are seen and centered when relationships break down; and where learning, adaptation and growth are baked into our expectations of how we live together. Leading restoratively doesn’t mean having the all the answers, but instead accepting responsibility for the questions we ask, the relationships we nurture, and the systems we participate in creating and sustaining.

Whether your initiative is large or small, urgent or strategic – we are ready to support you.

Let's Get Started